(General Discussion) Public voting in Metaforo

CKB Community Fund DAO
#1

I’m not sure if this was noted in the DAO information posted already, I can’t remember seeing it, but I’d like to bring this up for discussion.

When looking at the Nervos Nation proposal in Metaforo, I noticed that the voters and the number of votes they cast are publicly visible.

This creates a privacy issue, not only due to the revealing of holding amounts, which is especially a problem for doxxed members of the community, but also for voting choices.

I believe voting needs to be private so that everyone can feel free to vote on their conscience without any regard to possible backlash from others in the community.

We need as many members of the community to vote on these proposals as possible and I think public voting will create a disincentive for some members.

我不确定这是否在已经发布的DAO信息中注意到了，我不记得看到过，但我想提出来讨论一下。

在看Metaforo中的Nervos Nation提案时，我注意到选民和他们投的票数是公开可见的。

这造成了一个重大的隐私问题，不仅是由于持有金额的暴露，这对社区中的被攻击者来说尤其是一个问题，而且也是投票选择的问题。

我相信投票需要是私密的，这样每个人都可以自由地凭自己的良心投票，而不考虑社区中其他人可能的反感。

我们需要尽可能多的社区成员对这些提案进行投票，我认为公开投票会对一些成员产生抑制作用。

#2

Ok, my apologies, I think I’ve jumped the gun a bit here and didn’t think this through.

There is no reason you need to sign up to Metaforo with your real name or the username you use either on this site, or any other social media, so maintaining privacy is up to the user at that point.

But I’ll leave this here without deleting, just so people are aware that your Metaforo profile and the number of votes you cast are visible to everyone.

好吧，我很抱歉，我想我在这里有点操之过急，没有考虑清楚。

你没有理由需要用你在这个网站或任何其他社交媒体上使用的真实姓名或用户名来注册Metaforo，所以在这一点上维护隐私是由用户决定的。

但我还是把这个留在这里，不删除，只是让大家知道，你的Metaforo资料和你投的票数对大家来说是可见的。

2 Likes
#3

Thanks for the question and your addition.
I’ll briefly add that, as I understand it, the primary consideration here is to be able to show the address of the poll. In the future, Nervos’ DAO will go to on-chain governance, whose address should also be public.

So if anybody has privacy requirements, please don’t associate Metaforo’s name with social media.

感谢你的提问和自己提出的补充。
我简单的补充两句，按照我的理解，这里的主要考量是为了能展示出投票的地址，未来 Nervos 的 DAO 一定会走向链上治理，而链上治理的投票应该也是公开的。

所以如果对隐私有要求的小伙伴，可以不要把 Metaforo 的名字和社交媒体有关联。

3 Likes